Overall Scientific Merit and Impact
- Demonstrated strength in six essential characteristics of an NCI-designated Cancer Center:
- Physical Space: Appropriateness and adequacy of dedicated facilities for cancer research, Shared Resources, and administration.
- Organizational Capabilities: Effective promotion of collaborative scientific interactions and efficient administrative organization.
- Transdisciplinary Collaboration and Coordination: Substantial coordination, interaction, and collaboration among Center members and with external partners, enhancing research productivity and quality.
- Cancer Focus: Clear demonstration of cancer research focus through Research Programs, members' grants, publications, and collaborations.
- Institutional Commitment: Evidence of superior organizational status, sufficient funding, space, positions, and long-term stable support from the parent institution(s).
- Center Director: Qualifications, leadership experience, and effectiveness in managing the Center and advancing its scientific mission.
Quality of Research Programs and Productivity
- Each formal Research Program should be highly interactive, focused on cancer research, and have adequate size and quality for significant scientific impact.
- Research Programs must typically include at least seven fully cancer-focused, peer-reviewed funded research projects (equivalent to an NIH R01, meaning $125,000 direct costs per year for at least three years) from a minimum of five different, independent PD/PIs.
- Evidence of collaborative research projects, joint publications, and other meaningful interchanges.
- Effectiveness of scientific leadership within each Program.
Translational and Clinical Impact
- Ability to facilitate movement of scientific findings through the translational pipeline (e.g., from basic to clinical development).
- For Clinical and Comprehensive Cancer Centers: Quality and impact of clinical research, including accrual to clinical trials (national, institutional, industry-sponsored) and inclusion of diverse populations (women, minorities, individuals across the lifespan).
- Relevance of research to the Center's catchment area.
Community Outreach and Engagement (for Clinical and Comprehensive Centers)
- Scope, quality, and impact of activities in engaging the community and reducing the cancer burden within the defined catchment area.
- Thorough analysis of demographics and cancer burden in the catchment area.
- Partnerships with healthcare systems and community agencies for dissemination of evidence-based findings.
Infrastructure and Administrative Effectiveness
- Effectiveness of centralized Shared Resources in enhancing scientific interaction and productivity, ensuring stability, reliability, cost-effectiveness, and quality control.
- Rigor of processes for soliciting, reviewing, and selecting pilot projects and allocating Developmental Funds.
- Soundness of Clinical Protocol and Data Management (CPDM) for central oversight of clinical trials.
- Rigor of Protocol Review and Monitoring System (PRMS) for scientific oversight of all cancer clinical studies.
- Robustness of Data and Safety Monitoring (DSM) for clinical trials.