Excellence and Potential of Disruption (Weighted 2x, Max 5 points)
- Excellence of the overall concept and soundness of the proposed approach (ideas, technologies, methodology).
- Compliance with the topic's objectives, scope, activities, functional requirements, and expected impact.
- Extent to which the project's objective/outcome differs from existing defence products/technologies and represents a strategic, technological, or defence operational advantage, or shows potential for disruption in defence.
Innovation and Technological Development (Weighted 2x, Max 5 points)
- Demonstrated innovation potential, ground-breaking/novel concepts/approaches (e.g., new products, services, business/organizational models).
- New promising technological improvements, or application of technologies/concepts not previously applied in defence.
- Integration of existing knowledge and R&D activities (defence/civil) to avoid duplication.
- Potential for spin-offs to other defence applications/products.
Competitiveness (Weighted 1x, Max 5 points)
- Foreseen competitive advantage of the product/technology/solution compared to existing/planned solutions (EU and global).
- Consideration of balance between performance and cost-efficiency.
- Potential to accelerate growth of companies throughout the EU, including market analysis (size, growth potential, sales volumes).
- Strength of the IP strategy (e.g., patents) to support competitiveness and growth.
EDTIB Autonomy (Weighted 1x, Max 5 points)
- Contribution to the autonomy of the EU’s Defence Technological and Industrial Base (EDTIB) by increasing non-dependency from third countries.
- Beneficial impact on European security of supply, including creation of new supply chains.
- Contribution to defence capability priorities agreed by Member States (CFSP, Capability Development Plan). Alignment with regional/international priorities serving EU security/defence interests without excluding any Member State/EDF associated country.
Creation of New Cross-Border Cooperation (Weighted 2x, Max 5 points)
- Extent to which the project will create new cross-border cooperation between legal entities in Member States or EDF Associated Countries, especially SMEs and mid-caps.
- Planned future cross-border cooperation and opportunities created by activities.
- Substantial participation and industrial/technological added value brought by cross-border SMEs and mid-caps.
Implementation (Weighted 1x, Max 5 points)
- Effectiveness and practicality of the work plan structure (work breakdown, timing, inter-relation of work packages).
- Usefulness and comprehensiveness of milestones and deliverables; clarity of measurable, realistic, achievable criteria.
- Appropriateness of management structures and procedures, including decision-making and risk management (identification, assessment, treatments).
- Appropriateness of task/resource allocation among consortium members, ensuring valid and complementary roles, and high effectiveness/efficiency.
Scoring Details
- Individual criteria have no minimum pass score.
- Each criterion scored from 0 to 5 (half-points allowed).
- Overall threshold: 30 points (out of a maximum 45 points). Proposals must pass this threshold to be considered for funding.
- Priority Order (for same scores):
- Excellence and potential of disruption.
- Innovation and technological development.
- Competitiveness.
- Creation of new cross-border cooperation.
- Further prioritisation if needed, based on the number of Member States or EDF Associated Countries with involved applicants.