Applications are assessed in two stages, with specific scoring criteria at each stage. Only projects passing Stage I proceed to Stage II.
Stage I Evaluation (Obligatory - Pass/Fail)
To proceed to Stage II, your project must score
1 point on
each of the following 5 criteria (a score of 0 on any criterion means disqualification):
- Applicant Eligibility: Verification that your company meets all formal requirements regarding operational history, revenue, and legal status in Poland.
- Project Location: Confirmation that the project will be physically implemented within Poland.
- Biotechnology Sector Alignment: The project's alignment with the defined biotechnology sector and critical technologies/value chains as specified in the grant documents.
- Critical Technology Manufacturing: Confirmation that the project is focused on the 'manufacturing' aspect of critical technologies, as opposed to R&D or end-product installation.
- Exclusion Compliance: Verification that the project does not involve any activities explicitly excluded from funding, such as fossil fuels or military applications.
Stage II Evaluation (Scoring - Minimum 11 points, Maximum 26 points)
Projects are scored based on the following criteria, with specific point ranges and minimums:
-
Critical Technology Potential (0, 1, 2, 4, or 5 points): This is a crucial criterion evaluating whether the technology or its value chain component:
- Introduces an innovative, state-of-the-art, or breakthrough element to the EU internal market (requires at least two of these).
- Demonstrates significant economic potential by positively impacting the internal market, with effects beyond your current operations and potential for external impacts in other EU member states (e.g., economic growth, increased exports, new jobs, increased R&D investment in the EU).
- If a value chain project, contributes to the protection and strengthening of the critical technology value chain.
- Additional points (up to 4) are awarded for breakthrough technology or meeting all innovative/state-of-the-art/breakthrough conditions.
- Minimum required: 1 point.
-
Applicant Potential (0, 1, 2, or 3 points): Assesses your capacity to deliver the project:
- Readiness of investment actions, including necessary permits, licenses, and intellectual property rights (or their probable acquisition).
- Sufficiency of technical and human resources (including management team experience and project management structure).
- Clarity and realism of the project implementation schedule.
- Additional points (up to 2) are awarded for possessing a valid building permit (if applicable) or a demonstrated track record of successful market implementation of other biotech projects.
- Minimum required: 1 point.
-
Project Expenses and Public Aid Compliance (0 or 1 point): Ensures that:
- Requested eligible costs (minimum 10 million PLN) and maximum funding (up to 150 million PLN) comply with limits and intensity rates.
- All expenses are necessary, directly related to the project, reasonable, and correctly categorized.
- The project adheres to public aid regulations, including initial investment definitions, co-financing requirements (at least 25% of eligible costs), and specific aid categories (e.g., advisory, innovation, training, environmental).
- Minimum required: 1 point.
-
Financial Viability (0 or 1 point): Evaluation of whether you have adequate and credible funding sources (including own funds and external financing like loans) to cover all project costs, including co-financing.
- Minimum required: 1 point.
-
Project Profitability (0 or 1 point): Assessment of the project's financial feasibility based on financial forecasts (revenue, costs) and key indicators like Net Present Value (NPV) and Internal Rate of Return (IRR).
- Minimum required: 1 point.
-
Project Indicators (0 or 1 point): Checks for adequate, measurable, consistent, verifiable, and achievable product and outcome indicators, with clearly defined baseline, target values, and verification methods. Environmental indicators are assessed under 'Sustainable Development'.
- Minimum required: 1 point.
-
Incentive Effect (0 or 1 point): Confirms that the project has not commenced before the application submission date. Exceptions apply for some 'de minimis' aid costs.
- Minimum required: 1 point.
-
Sustainable Development (0 or 1 point): Assesses compliance with EU sustainable development principles, 'Do No Significant Harm' (DNSH), and the UN SDGs. This includes demonstrating positive environmental impact (e.g., adherence to at least two '6R principles' - refuse, reduce, reuse, recover, recycle, rethink - or other positive environmental aspects), supported by relevant environmental indicators.
- Minimum required: 1 point.
-
Equal Opportunities and Non-discrimination (0 or 1 point): Ensures the project promotes equal opportunities and non-discrimination, including accessibility for people with disabilities and gender equality, aligning with relevant EU guidelines.
- Minimum required: 1 point.
-
Compliance with the Charter of Fundamental Rights (0 or 1 point): Verifies the project's adherence to the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights (specifically Articles 1, 3-8, 10, 15, 20-23, 25-28, 30-33).
- Minimum required: 1 point.
-
Compliance with the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (0 or 1 point): Confirms alignment with the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (specifically Articles 2-7, 9, 27).
- Minimum required: 1 point.
Facultative Criterion (Additional Points)
- Project Impact Scope (0, 3, 6, or 9 points): Assesses the broader positive societal, economic, environmental, or climate impacts beyond the project's direct goals. Points are awarded if the project:
- Increases your company's global market significance.
- Demonstrates significant market growth potential for the critical technology (EU and international).
- Positively influences competitiveness and market structure.
- Achieving one of these adds 3 points, two adds 6 points, and all three adds 9 points.
Tie-Breaking Criteria
If multiple projects achieve the same score and funding is insufficient for all, the following criteria will determine priority:
1.
National Key Cluster Membership: Preference for applicants who have been a member of a National Key Cluster for at least 6 months prior to application.
2.
Woman-led Enterprise: Preference for applicants where at least one woman has been a partner, shareholder, or management board member actively involved in decision-making for at least 6 months prior to application.