Overall Impact
Reviewers will provide an overall impact score reflecting the likelihood for the project to exert a sustained, powerful influence on the research field(s) involved.
Scored Review Criteria
- Significance: Assesses how the proposed activities, including those at foreign sites, will improve racial/ethnic minority health and/or assist in reducing or eliminating health disparities in the United States. This includes whether the work addresses an important unmet need or solves an unaddressed problem in racial/ethnic minority health or health disparities.
Additional Review Criteria (Considered, but Not Scored)
- Study Timeline.
- Applications with Foreign Components.
Funding Decision Factors
After scientific peer review, funding decisions will consider:
- Scientific and technical merit of the proposed project.
- Availability of funds.
- Relevance of the proposed project to program priorities (i.e., improving minority health and eliminating health disparities).
- Security risk as assessed by the HHS Due Diligence Program, particularly regarding ties to foreign countries of concern.
Innovation Requirements
Applicants must explicitly identify the
innovative elements of the proposed research and product development, and discuss how these elements may lead to improving minority health or reducing/eliminating one or more health disparities.
Social Impact Expectations
- The proposed technology, service, or product must be designed to be effective, affordable, culturally acceptable, and easily accessible to racial/ethnic minorities and other populations experiencing health disparities.
- It should be designed to be unlikely to contribute to sustaining or creating a health disparity.
- Applicants are encouraged to leverage the NIMHD Research Framework to inform product conceptualization and design, which identifies factors within socioecological domains that influence health outcomes.
Competitive Advantage Factors
Applicants should discuss:
- How the proposed approach and product are informed by the lived experiences and needs of racial/ethnic minorities or health disparity populations.
- The involvement and role of potential partners in furthering the goals toward improving minority health and reducing health disparities.
- How the work will use concepts or theories from biomedical, social-behavioral, minority health, or health disparities sciences to guide research and product development efforts.
- The organization's and/or partners' demonstrated history of success in working with racial and ethnic minorities or other populations that experience health disparities.