The detailed award criteria, scoring, and thresholds for evaluation are outlined in Annex D of the Horizon Europe Work Programme General Annexes, which was not provided in the grant materials. However, based on the 'Scope' and 'Expected Outcomes' sections, the following aspects are critical for a successful proposal:
Strategic Relevance and Impact
- Contribution to Civil Security: How effectively the project contributes to forming a community of EU civil security practitioners with shared needs and supports an industrial base (especially SMEs and Startups) to access the public procurement market and scale up their business.
- Market Uptake & Commercialisation: The potential for increased market uptake and economies of scale for innovative solutions, and how procurers facilitate commercialization by successful suppliers.
- Policy Alignment: Support for public procurers in collectively implementing PCPs to drive innovation and open up wider commercialization opportunities for European companies.
- Sustainability and Exploitation: Clear commitment to exploiting project results beyond its conclusion, ensuring engagement with stakeholders and implementing strategies for future uptake.
Quality and Implementation of the Project
- Problem Definition: Clear evidence to justify and de-risk the PCP action, demonstrating that the identified challenge is significant and necessitates a PCP approach to mature technologies and compare alternatives.
- Technical Approach: Analysis of the state-of-the-art and market landscape, aligning research with identified needs, and presenting a range of technical alternatives.
- PCP Process Design: A well-defined tendering process, supported by a draft plan, including readiness of documentation and administrative procedures. The competitive development should lead to at least 2 prototypes from 2 different providers validated in a real operational environment.
- Consortium Quality: Demonstrated commitment from a consolidated group of practitioners and procurers with shared needs and requirements for the PCP process, enabling informed decisions.
- Stakeholder Engagement: Involvement of procurement decision-makers to ensure adoption of solutions, and clear plans for post-PCP activities.
- Open Market Consultations: Evidence of conducting open market consultations in at least three EU Member States.
Cross-Cutting Themes
- Gender Dimension: Integration of the gender dimension (sex and gender analysis) in research and innovation content should be addressed only if relevant to the objectives of the research effort.