Standard Horizon Europe Evaluation Criteria
- Proposals will be evaluated based on three main criteria: Excellence, Impact, and Quality and efficiency of the implementation.
- External independent experts will assess the quality of proposals against these criteria.
Financial Aspects of Evaluation
- Experts with financial knowledge will review the detailed budget estimate provided by applicants.
- The budget will be checked against relevant benchmarks such as market prices, statistical data, and historical data from comparable actions.
- Experts will assess whether the proposed resources and the breakdown of lump sum shares are sufficient and appropriate for achieving the outlined activities and expected outputs.
- Applicants must confirm that their estimated budget was prepared following their own accounting practices.
- The final lump sum amount in the grant agreement will be adjusted based on the findings and recommendations from this financial assessment.
Expected Outcomes and Impact (Specific to this Topic)
Proposals should contribute to all of the following expected outcomes:
- EU institutions, national decision-makers, practitioners, and civil society organizations are better equipped to confront and prevent mis- and disinformation, while respecting freedom of expression.
- EU institutions and national decision-makers gain a better understanding of stakeholders opposing anti-disinformation policies, including their narratives and drivers, to improve engagement.
- EU institutions and national decision-makers understand how digital media shapes public opinion and can regulate it without compromising citizens' rights to information, media freedom, privacy, and data protection.
In addition, proposals should contribute to at least one of the following:
- Media, education, and security practitioners become more knowledgeable about tools and legal remedies to counter narratives opposing anti-disinformation policies.
- EU institutions and national decision-makers better understand the role of independent media, 'media dissemination hubs,' and 'professional mediators' in facilitating access to professionally produced content.
- EU institutions, national decision-makers, and media practitioners understand astroturfing, its use in spreading mis/disinformation, and are equipped with tools and policy recommendations to counter it.
- Relevant actors have adequate educational materials to design and implement initiatives against mis/disinformation without harming freedom of expression.
Scope and Research Focus
- Investigation into how media systems (especially data-driven ones) foster disinformation, including gendered disinformation and anti-LGBTIQ rhetoric.
- Exploration of market incentives for media that promote mis- and disinformation.
- Development of regulations to counter disinformation that comply with fundamental rights, such as freedom of expression and pluralistic news media.
- Design and management of trust indicators and comparison tools for online news media (e.g., browser plugins, journalism trust indicators) to help citizens distinguish journalistic content from opinions.
- Research into the role of 'professional mediators' (journalists, editors) and 'media dissemination hubs' in shaping public discourse.
- Development of policy recommendations and methodologies for legal safeguards protecting open civic discourse (e.g., against Holocaust denial, hate speech).
- Emphasis on building upon past EU-funded projects and collaborating with ongoing ones.
- Requirement to involve a wide range of stakeholders, including non-scientific and non-academic actors (e.g., public bodies, policymakers, private corporates, media organizations, NGOs, CSOs, fact-checkers, educational bodies, cultural heritage institutions).
- Encouragement to use participative methodologies and experimental methods.
- Where applicable, proposals should leverage data and services from European Research Infrastructures, European Open Science Cloud (EOSC), and relevant Data Spaces. Data produced should be FAIR (Findable, Accessible, Interoperable and Re-usable).