Reviewers will assign an overall impact score reflecting the project's likelihood of exerting a sustained, powerful influence on the research field(s), based on the following criteria:
Scored Review Criteria
These three factors will determine the scientific merit and contribute to the overall impact score, with Factors 1 and 2 also receiving separate criterion scores:
-
Factor 1. Importance of the Research (Significance and Innovation): Evaluates the project's potential to advance scientific knowledge and its originality.
-
Factor 2. Rigor and Feasibility (Approach): Assesses the soundness, design, methods, and analyses of the proposed research, as well as the feasibility of execution.
-
Factor 3. Expertise and Resources (Investigator(s) and Environment): Considers the qualifications and experience of the research team and the suitability of the research environment and resources.
Additional Review Criteria (Considered, but not scored separately)
- Protections for Human Subjects: Evaluation of the proposed measures to protect human research participants.
- Vertebrate Animals: Assessment of procedures, justification for animal use, and efforts to minimize discomfort, distress, pain, and injury if live vertebrate animals are involved.
- Biohazards: Review of significant hazardous materials or procedures and the adequacy of proposed protection measures.
- Resubmissions: Comprehensive re-evaluation of the entire application as presented.
- Renewals: Evaluation of the progress achieved during the previous funding period.
- Revisions: Assessment of the appropriateness and justification for the proposed expansion of the project's scope.
Additional Review Considerations (Considered, but not scored or for overall impact)
- Authentication of Key Biological and/or Chemical Resources: Review of brief plans for identifying and ensuring the validity of essential biological and/or chemical resources.
- Budget and Period of Support: Evaluation of whether the requested budget and project duration are fully justified and reasonable in relation to the proposed research scope and objectives.