Scored Review Criteria
Reviewers will provide an
Overall Impact score, reflecting the project's likelihood to exert a sustained, powerful influence on the research field(s) involved. This score is determined by assessing the following three core criteria, which also receive separate criterion scores:
- 1. Importance of the Research (Significance and Innovation):
- Significance: How well the project links mechanisms and/or risk factors to NPS across multiple levels of analysis (e.g., genetic, cellular, brain circuit, physiological, behavioral, self-report) in a way that can inform novel intervention development. It should clarify the neurobiological and/or behavioral mechanisms underlying NPS syndromes in AD/ADRD.
- Innovation: How the proposed paradigm, model, and/or assay offers a significant improvement over the current state of the science, particularly in advancing scientific knowledge towards linking mechanisms and/or risk factors to NPS. This includes integrating multiple levels of analysis to understand the dynamic relationships between NPS symptoms and AD pathogenesis.
- 2. Rigor and Feasibility (Approach):
- The appropriateness of the theoretical justification for the proposed approach and its potential to advance scientific understanding of NPS mechanisms.
- For imaging studies, the examination of neural circuits involved in NPS in AD/ADRD compared to other neuropsychiatric diseases.
- For animal studies, the use of well-validated models of the involved circuitry with corresponding validated behavioral assays.
- Emphasis on rigor and transparency in experimental design, adhering to guidelines like NOT-OD-15-103 and NOT-MH-14-004.
- 3. Expertise and Resources (Investigator(s) and Environment):
- The qualifications, experience, and leadership of the Program Director(s)/Principal Investigator(s) and other key personnel.
- The adequacy and appropriateness of the institutional environment and facilities for the proposed research.
- Access to necessary resources for successful project completion.
Additional Review Criteria (Not Scored, but Considered for Overall Impact)
- Protections for Human Subjects: Evaluation of plans for participant protection and ethical conduct.
- Vertebrate Animals: Assessment of procedures involving animals, justification for use, interventions to minimize discomfort, and justification for euthanasia (if applicable).
- Biohazards: Evaluation of hazards to research personnel or the environment and proposed protections.
- Resubmissions/Renewals/Revisions: Evaluation of previous feedback, progress, or appropriateness of scope expansion.
Additional Review Considerations (Not Scored)
- Authentication of Key Biological and/or Chemical Resources: Plans for validating resources.
- Budget and Period of Support: Justification and reasonableness of the requested budget and project duration in relation to the proposed research.
Quality Thresholds and Excellence Benchmarks
The grant prioritizes research that is not only scientifically sound but also highly innovative, rigorous, and translatable. This includes:
* Utilizing cutting-edge methodologies from fields such as cognitive and affective neuroscience, including neuroimaging, neurophysiology, gene expression, epigenetics, and behavioral intervention research.
* Employing constructs from NIMH's Research Domain Criteria (RDoC) initiative or compatible dimensional approaches to assess NPS.
* Proposing research that identifies modifiable targets for intervention development.
Cross-Cutting Themes Impact on Scoring
While not explicit scoring criteria, research that incorporates the following is encouraged and aligns with funder priorities, potentially enhancing the application's overall impact:
* Examining molecular mechanisms of NPS in AD/ADRD across populations of
diverse ethnic and racial backgrounds.
* Focusing on understanding the impact of
sex differences on the molecular mechanisms of NPS in AD/ADRD.
* Strong commitment to
data sharing to enable reproducible and translatable discovery research and facilitate meta-analyses, contributing to scientific sustainability.