The evaluation of proposals for this grant focuses on several key areas, each contributing to an overall score. The maximum total score is 45 points, with an overall threshold of
30 points for a proposal to be considered for funding. For this specific topic, only the highest-ranked proposal will be funded.
Excellence and Potential of Disruption (Weight: 2, Max: 5 points)
- Quality of the overall concept and soundness of the proposed approach, including ideas, technologies, and methodology.
- Compliance with the grant's objectives, scope, types of activities, functional requirements, and expected impact.
- Degree to which the proposed project's objective and expected outcome are significantly different from (and strategically or operationally advantageous over) existing defence products or technologies, or show potential for disruption in the defence sector.
Innovation and Technological Development (Weight: 2, Max: 5 points)
- Demonstration of innovation potential and the presence of ground-breaking or novel concepts (e.g., new products, services, business/organizational models), promising technological improvements, or new applications of technologies in the defence sector.
- Integration of existing knowledge and previous R&D activities (defence and civil) while avoiding unnecessary duplication.
- Potential for the developed innovations or technologies to 'spin-off' into other defence applications and products.
Competitiveness (Weight: 1, Max: 5 points)
- Anticipated competitive advantage of the product/technology/solution compared to existing or planned solutions within the EU and globally, considering the balance between performance and cost-efficiency.
- Potential to accelerate growth for companies across the EU, based on market analysis and expected sales volumes.
- Strength of the Intellectual Property (IP) strategy (e.g., patents) supporting the competitiveness and growth of applicant companies.
EDTIB Autonomy (European Defence Technological and Industrial Base) (Weight: 1, Max: 5 points)
- Contribution of the proposed project to increasing the EU's industrial and technological non-dependency from third countries.
- Positive impact on the European security of supply, including the creation of new supply chains.
- Alignment with defence capability priorities agreed by EU Member States within the Common Foreign and Security Policy (CFSP).
Creation of New Cross-Border Cooperation (Weight: 2, Max: 5 points)
- Extent to which the project establishes new cross-border cooperation among legal entities in EU Member States or EDF associated countries, particularly SMEs and mid-caps, compared to previous activities in this technological area.
- Description of planned future cross-border cooperation and opportunities created by the project.
- Degree of substantial participation by cross-border SMEs and mid-caps, and the industrial or technological added value they contribute.
Implementation (Weight: 1, Max: 5 points)
- Effectiveness and practicality of the work plan structure, including timing and inter-relation of work packages.
- Usefulness and comprehensiveness of project milestones and deliverables, with clear, measurable, realistic, and achievable criteria.
- Appropriateness of management structures and procedures, including decision-making mechanisms, for the project's complexity and scale.
- Quality of risk management, including identification and assessment of critical risks and proposed mitigation measures.
- Appropriateness of task and resource allocation among consortium members, ensuring valid and complementary roles for effective and efficient project execution.
Scoring Scale
- 0: Fails to address the criterion or insufficient information.
- 1: Poor; inadequately addressed or serious weaknesses.
- 2: Fair; broadly addressed but significant weaknesses.
- 3: Good; addressed well but some shortcomings.
- 4: Very Good; addressed very well but minor shortcomings.
- 5: Excellent; successfully addresses all relevant aspects, minor shortcomings.