Evaluation Criteria
Proposals are evaluated based on three main criteria, each scored from 0 to 5. A minimum score of 3/5 is required for each criterion, and an overall score of at least 10/15 is needed to be considered for funding.
1. Excellence
- Objectives and Ambition: Clarity and pertinence of the project's objectives. The proposal must be ambitious and demonstrate how it advances beyond the current state-of-the-art.
- Methodology: Soundness of the proposed methodology, including the underlying concepts, models, and assumptions. This includes the quality of inter-disciplinary approaches and open science practices. The integration of the gender dimension (sex and/or gender analysis) should be addressed if relevant to the research.
2. Impact
- Pathway to Impact: Credibility of the pathways to achieve the expected outcomes and impacts specified in the work programme. This includes the likely scale and significance of the project's contributions to:
- Modern tools and skills for security practitioners.
- Improved cross-border information exchange.
- Evidence-based support for policymakers.
- Measures to Maximise Impact: Suitability and quality of the plan for dissemination, exploitation, and communication of project results. This includes strategies for future uptake and upscaling at national and EU levels.
3. Quality and Efficiency of the Implementation
- Work Plan and Resources: Quality and effectiveness of the work plan, including a thorough assessment of risks and the appropriateness of the effort and resources assigned to each work package.
- Consortium Capacity: The capacity and role of each participant must be clearly described. The evaluation will assess the extent to which the consortium as a whole brings together the necessary expertise to achieve the project's goals.
Special Evaluation Rule: Portfolio Approach
- To ensure a balanced portfolio of funded projects, grants will be awarded not only in order of their ranking but also to ensure at least one project is funded from each of the three topic options (a, b, and c), provided it is the highest-ranked in its option and meets all scoring thresholds.